The value of a kilowatt-hour depends on when it is made

For a long time, many homeowners with rooftop solar were billed under simple net metering: every kilowatt-hour sent to the grid offset a kilowatt-hour bought from the grid at the same retail price, no matter what time of day it happened. That made the value of solar easy to estimate. Increasingly, utilities and regulators are moving away from that model. Time-of-use rates, changes to export credits and new fixed charges mean the value of solar now depends heavily on when electricity is produced and used.

This article explains the main trends in utility rate design and what they mean for the residential solar market. Rates and rules differ by utility and change through regulatory proceedings, so always check your own utility's current tariffs.

What time-of-use rates are

Under a time-of-use rate, the price of electricity changes depending on the time of day, and sometimes the season or day of the week. Peak hours, when demand on the grid is highest, cost more. Off-peak hours cost less. In many regions with lots of solar, peak periods have shifted later into the evening, because solar output floods the grid at midday and then drops as the sun sets while household demand stays high.

For solar owners, this matters because panels produce most of their energy in the middle of the day. If midday electricity is priced as off-peak, the solar output is offsetting cheaper power than it would under a flat rate.

From net metering to net billing

A related trend is the move from full retail net metering to net billing or other export tariffs. Under net billing, electricity you use directly from your panels still offsets what you would have bought, but power exported to the grid earns a credit that may be lower than the retail price, often based on the utility's avoided cost or a value-of-solar calculation. California's move to a net billing tariff in 2023 is the best-known example, and regulators in other states have considered or adopted their own changes.

The result is that exported energy can be worth noticeably less than energy used at home. The more of your solar output you consume yourself, the more valuable it becomes.

Fixed charges and minimum bills

Some utilities have added or proposed higher fixed monthly charges, minimum bills or charges specific to customers with solar. These reduce the share of a bill that solar can offset, because no amount of solar generation eliminates a fixed charge. The level and design of these charges are often debated in rate cases, where utilities, consumer advocates and solar groups argue over how grid costs should be shared.

What this means for system design

Rate design is changing how installers design and sell systems:

  • Batteries gain relevance. A battery can store midday solar output and discharge it during expensive evening hours, instead of exporting it for a lower credit. Where rates reward this, battery attachment becomes more attractive.
  • Panel orientation gets a second look. West-facing panels produce less in total than south-facing ones, but more of their output arrives later in the day, closer to peak periods.
  • System sizing changes. When exports earn little, oversizing a system to export lots of energy makes less sense. Systems may be sized more closely to on-site use.
  • Load shifting matters. Running dishwashers, laundry, water heating or electric vehicle charging during sunny hours increases self-consumption.

Why utilities are making these changes

Utilities and regulators generally argue that time-varying rates better reflect the actual cost of supplying power at different times, and that export credits under full net metering can shift costs to customers without solar. Solar advocates counter that rooftop solar provides benefits that simpler rate designs undervalue, such as reduced strain on distribution networks and lower need for new generation. Where each state lands depends on its regulators, legislation and local grid conditions.

How homeowners and analysts should read the trend

The direction of travel in many markets is toward rates that make timing matter more. That does not necessarily make solar a poor investment, but it makes simple payback estimates less reliable. Anyone evaluating solar should:

  • Find out which rate plan a solar customer would be placed on, and whether it is mandatory.
  • Ask how exported energy is credited, and whether that rule is locked in for a period or can change.
  • Look at hourly or monthly usage patterns, not just the annual total.
  • Model scenarios with and without a battery, using conservative assumptions.

Rate design has become one of the main forces shaping the residential solar market, alongside equipment costs and incentives. For a deeper look at storage, see our guide to home battery storage, and for an alternative to rooftop panels, read about community solar programs.

About Recentsun

Independent analysis of solar market trends, costs, policy and incentives, written without invented statistics. Learn more.

Newsletter